What To Look For In An AR15 Bolt Carrier Group

A Bravo Company Manufacturing Bolt Carrier Group in it's proper home.

With the holiday season approaching, you might be itching for a gift of the ballistic variety. Maybe you’re already looking for something to change on that AR15 you just got this past year. And there’s nothing wrong with that. Good can always be better. A popular and stupendously-easy upgrade is to purchase a bolt carrier group for your AR15.

There’s a dizzying array of coatings, specs, and options for an AR15 bolt carrier group aka a BCG. So, what goes into the best bolt carrier group for your AR15?

But, before we do this deep dive into a rather esoteric part of the AR15, let’s stop for a bit.

You May Not Really Need To Upgrade Your Bolt Carrier Group

If you purchased a quality AR-15, such as one from Aero Precision, Sons of Liberty Gunworks, Spike’s Tactical, or Geissele - you’ll probably not need to upgrade the bolt carrier group in your firearm. These, and other reputable AR manufacturers often make, or at least do the finishing (more on that later) on their own bolt carrier groups, and to them, it’s a point of pride and utility to have one that works. So, if you managed to score an AR15 from one of those wonderful ballistic badasses, you don’t need to upgrade your bolt carrier group. Of course, if you want to know more regardless - read on. Or go listen to my podcast.

BCG

What Goes Into A Bolt Carrier Group

On the off-chance you’ve made it this far, and you aren’t sure just what a bolt carrier group is, here you go:

The Bolt Carrier Group (BCG) is a critical component of the AR-15 (or M16/M4). The BCG is the “action” of the rifle. It loads a new round into the chamber, fires that round, extracts and ejects the spent casing, cocks the hammer and repeats the process.

Note: In this article we are covering bolt carrier groups for standard direct-impingement AR-style firearms. Chances are, your AR-15 is a direct impingement gun, which is to say the gun operates by redirecting some of the gas directly back into the chamber, pushing the BCG back to eject the spent cartridge and load a new round.

Some more expensive ARs operate using a gas-piston system where the redirected gases push a piston, which pushes the BCG - this is similar to how an AK-style rifle operates. We’ll cover that world in a future article.

OK with that out of the way - a bolt carrier group is made up of several components.

  • Carrier. This is the external housing for the bolt and is attached to the gas key. It’s important to clean and check it regularly to ensure that the screws attaching it to the gas key do not come loose, and also for signs of excessive wear, cracks, etc.

  • Bolt. The bolt helps guide the round into the chamber, extracts the spent case, then ejects the spent cartridge once you’ve fired the gun.

  • Gas key. Also called the “bolt carrier key”, this essential part funnels gas from the gas tube into the bolt carrier. It should be tight and staked to create a seal. Proper staking keeps screws from backing out.

  • Firing pin. A firing pin is a component that strikes the primer of a cartridge, igniting it and causing a small explosion to propel the projectile forward.

  • Cam Pin. The Cam Pin keeps the bolt inside the bolt carrier and keeps it in line, it keeps the firing pin in line, it “cams” the bolt into the locked position as the BCG finishes its forward movement into battery, and it provides many more functions that are crucial to the operation of the firearm. “Battery” is a firearms term for being ready to fire.

Types Of AR15 Bolt Carrier Groups

When going out to select a nifty new BCG for your AR-15, you’ll be presented with an extensive array of styles. The main types can be broken down into some basic groups though.

M16 Or Full Auto Bolt Carrier Group

“Full auto - but wait, don’t I need to be a manufacturer or jump through all these bureaucratic hoops to have a ‘full auto’ anything?”

In this case - no. The full-auto bolt carrier group for your AR-15 is named as such because it was developed as the BCG for the M16 and M4 rifles. It has more material on the “back” of the carrier in order to trip an auto sear, which is the critical component to enable full-auto operation. Without it, your rifle only functions in semi-auto.

Having a full-auto BCG in a semi-auto only AR is perfectly legal around the country.

As a matter of fact, the full-auto style is now the standard style for BCGs. It’s higher mass ensures smooth operation and more reliable cycling of the weapon.

A full-auto BCG can be considered “mil-spec” or better, provided it is made of the proper material, typically the bolt itself consisting of Carpenter 158 steel, and the carrier being 9310 or 8620 steel, with 9310 being a little more sturdy. For reference, 8620 steel is the material used in M4 bolts. You’ll be fine with 8620 steel.

Semi-Auto AR-15 Bolt Carrier Groups

AR-15s used to ship with semi-auto only bolt carrier groups, and some low-end models still do. But in my experience, you have to work to find those. These BCGs shaved down the “back” of the carrier, denying it the ability to trip an auto sear or lightning link for full-auto operation. Generally, you don’t want this sort of BCG, since they tend to be less reliable than their standard full-auto counterparts.

Again, the standard is full-auto - but double check when purchasing to be safe.

Low-Mass Bolt Carrier Groups

Some companies pride themselves on making what are called “low-mass“ bolt carrier groups. These BCGs strip out weight wherever possible, while still maintaining full functionality. They’ll look like cheese graters and you’ll wonder if they work well. Some do, some don’t. Low-mass BCGs are mainly targeted at those who build rilfes for competition, or those who play the game of building the lightest AR-15 possible. If you have the cash and time, indulge yourself. However, my gut tells me I wouldn’t want a low-mass BCG in my defensive rifle.

A Toolcraft Full Auto Bolt Carrier Group.

Materials and Coatings

Beyond the specific types of AR-15 bolt carrier groups, there’s a world of materials and coatings. To keep it basic, we’ll cover the common ones, of course.

Materials

Steel AR-15 Bolt Carrier Groups

Various grades of steel make up the most common AR-15 bolt carrier groups. Typically, the carrier itself is machined from 8620 or 9310 steel, with the bolt itself being Carpenter 158. The firing pin may be 8740 steel and chrome-plated for longevity. The gas key itself may be 4140 steel. The bolt itself is Carpenter 158? Confused? Yeah, me too. Those numbers refer to the composition, usage and hardness of the steel used. Generally you are good with the combinations I listed though.

For reference, a bolt-carrier group found in a military-issue M4 from FN or Colt will usually use 8620 in the carrier and Carpenter 158 in the bolt itself.

Titanium Bolt Carrier Groups

Titanium is an incredibly durable and resistant material, as well as being lightweight. It’s also not incredibly common and difficult to work with. Thus, expensive. An AR-15 bolt carrier group made out of 6AI-4V Grade 5 titanium can run more than double the cost of a comparable steel BCG. However, if you’re in the ounces-turn-into-pounds game, it could be worth it. The advantage of course is that it’s a softer recoil - but if you’ve trained on a “normal” BCG, you probably won’t notice. Get one if you want.

Aluminum Bolt Carrier Groups

While not as expensive as titanium BCGs, aluminum ones still manage to be lighter than traditional steel ones. The general use case for aluminum BCGs is in competition use, where again, ounces turn into pounds as they say. The downside is that aluminum is a softer metal and will wear faster. However, if you are competing, you’re blowing through so much ammo during training and running courses, that an extra $150-$200 on top of that isn’t going to make you cry.

Coatings

It seems every week that some manufacturer comes up with some new whiz-bang coating for an AR bolt carrier group. This is actually pretty normal since most bolt carrier group manufacturers actually only do the “finishing” of their BCGs. They source the raw components from elsewhere - in reality there’s only a few companies that actually make a bolt carrier group. One such OEM is Toolcraft, for example. A company will source from Toolcraft, put their own proprietary coating on it, laser on their logo, and call it a day.

That being said, there’s a few major types of coatings for AR bolt carrier groups.

Parkerized Manganese Phosphate

This coating is the military-spec one. The AR sitting in your safe right now probably has this coating. It’s matte dark grey/black, resists corrosion, and holds up extremely well under stress. Don’t shy away from it just because it’s “common”. It’s harder to clean since the texture holds fouling, but not by much.

Nickel-Boron (NiB) Coating

Nickel-Boron is an extremely durable and smooth coating, with a low friction quality. If you pick it up, it actually feels slippery all on it’s own. Generally glossy-silver in appearance, the coating is super-easy to clean, especially since you can see the fouling easier. Some manufacturers will then use a proprietary color process - which usually does nothing but add color and cost. NiB runs a little pricey, but if you can swing it, go for it.

Black Nitride

Black Nitride renders your BCG in a glossy black finish. I’m partial to it, it just looks badass. It’s actually not a coating, but a full-on steel treatment that hardens the BCG more and imparts an impressive corrosion resistance. It’s also very low-friction.

A Note On Coatings

In your research, you may see claims that BCGs coated a certan way can run “dry”. Truth be told, any BCG can run dry, the specific coating only allows it to do so for a longer period of time. However, I wouldn’t recommend running a bolt carrier group dry in a rifle you plan on utilizing in a defensive scenario. Keep it lubed up, regardless of the claims of “lubricity”.

GRITR FN 509

Testing A Bolt Carrier Group

Any reputable manufacturer will state their testing protocol for their bolt carrier groups. The tests determine whether the BCG can hold up under stress and pressure. Your BCG is the “heart” of your rifle - it needs to hold up. Generally, two tests are performed. Magnetic Particle Inspection (MPI) and High Pressure Testing (HPT). A quality BCG will be proof-marked (engraved) with “MPI/HPT” or something similar if it’s been through the process.

Magnetic Particle Inspection

Magnetic Particle Inspection, or MPI, is where the bolt carrier group is magnetized and then temporarily coated with magnetic iron particles, usually themselves coated with a dye that reacts to ultraviolet light. The particles will group themselves in defects and cracks (if any) and glow intensely under the UV light.

High Pressure Testing

High Pressure Testing, or HPT, subjects the BCG to pressures generally in excess of the usual pressure of the firing sequence. This overpressure tests to see if the BCG can hold up to sustained live firing.

Brownells

A Bravo Company Manufacturing M16-style Bolt Carrier Group.

The Best Bolt Carrier Group For Your AR-15

Well, now that you know a little about bolt carrier groups, you can go forth and seek out the best one for your rifle. My personal favorite is the BCM bolt carrier group. Made to exceed military specifications, it just keeps going and going. I’ve run thousands of rounds off of mine and there’s been zero malfunctions attributable to this BCG. CMC also makes an amazing one, and I’m glad to see they are in this game, as well.

BCGCostBuy Now
BCM M16 BCG$189.00Buy Now!
CMC Nitride BCG$199.00Buy Now!
PSA Nitride BCG$119.00Buy Now!

A Little Factory Tour Of BCM

Support This Site

Operating Regular Guy Guns and bringing you quality content costs money, money that I am more than happy to spend. I’m not really sponsored yet, so I have to pay for pretty much everything. However, I’m only able to do so much at a certain pace.

You’ll see the articles peppered with affiliate links. I get a few pennies when you make your purchases via my links.

With that in mind I’m offering a whole spectrum of specialty t-shirts, stickers, and daily wear accesories with my own brand of low-key humor. Be a Second Amendment Radical In Style! You’ll also notice affiliate links throughout the articles on this site. Go ahead and click on them and make your purchases. A few pennies and forints go to yours truly.

ammo for sale

Click here to accessorize your life.

Subscribe To The Regular Guy Podcast

Now available on Apple Podcasts!

A big thank you to The Magshack for the continued support.

Do me a favor and follow me on the gram.


|